"A Challenge"

Marley Erwin had been waiting for Marley Levi to return with Paradis Levi for almost an hour now, and he was getting impatient. Where the hell were they? They’d simply gone to Marley Levi’s room to get the Paradisian some new clothes, as his were dirtied from wearing them too many days in a row. After the hour passed, he got up, getting irritated with the two. What could be taking so long? All the other Levi needed to do was shower and get dressed.

Erwin walked down the hallway and pushed open his Levi’s bedroom door, walking in and slamming the door behind him. But it took him a moment to recognize what was going on, his mouth opening to shout at the two, but his words getting caught in his throat. He couldn’t help but stare: the two Levi’s were naked, with the other Levi on all fours on the bed, practically drooling as his Levi pounded into his ass from behind.

“Oh my god,” were the surprised words that escaped his mouth, and the two looked up from what they were doing, both turning a deep shade of red.

His Levi adjusted his glasses, which were getting foggy from their activities, “Uh, hi Ervy.”

“So this is what was taking so long,” Erwin said with wide eyes before a mischievous grin appeared on his face, “Move over, Levi. I want a turn.”

“Who says you get a turn?!” The Paradisian glared at him, letting out a groan when his counterpart continued to fuck him in short bursts.

“Yeah,” his Levi agreed, gripping the other Levi’s ass in his hands, “Who says you get a turn, Ervy? I was fucking him first!”

Erwin pouted, not having expected that answer. He almost always got what he wanted, and he started walking over the bed to physically separate the two, as he was intent on fucking at least one of them. His Levi removed himself from the Paradisian, a little more afraid of his Erwin than the Paradis Levi was.

The other Levi glared up at him, “You’re not getting anywhere near my ass.”

Erwin chuckled and shrugged, “I’ll fuck either one of you. I could take turns fucking you both.”

“Or,” Paradis Levi looked up at him, “We could take turns on you.”

Erwin raised an eyebrow, him and his Levi exchanging a look before the bespectacled Marleyan smiled at his clone’s suggestion, “Yeah, Ervy. We’re gonna fuck you instead. Now bend over.”

“Oh really?” Erwin laughed, “I’d like to see you try.”

He had to admit he was a little bit cocky. He just didn’t think the two little men could take him. But the Levi’s were staring at him with some mischief on their faces now. It was almost creepy; how they could seemingly read what the other wanted to do with a simple glance.

“Is that a challenge, Erwin?” The other Levi smirked, sitting up on the bed and reaching for Erwin’s arm. His Levi reached for his other arm, and soon Erwin found himself being bent over the side of the bed. The Paradisian stood quickly, pinning his lower half with his legs, whilst his Levi sat on his back pinned his arms above his head.

He laughed softly, squirming underneath the two. He was becoming a little surprised as he realized he couldn’t move, and that the two had him pinned there. He’d thought he was much stronger than the two, as he was used to tossing his Levi around like a rag doll during sex.

“Not so cocky anymore, are we?” Paradis Levi murmured, hooking his fingers in Erwin’s pants, “Would you like this to continue?”

Erwin grumbled some swears under his breath, squirming a little. But he had to admit, this was quite a turn-on: being trapped under the two Levi’s and fully at their whim. His Levi was already leaned over him, mouthing hungrily at his neck and nibbling lightly at a sensitive spot. He couldn’t help the small groan that escaped him, still wriggling uncomfortably. He just wasn’t used to being in this position; he was usually on the other end - pinning his Levi down and making him writhe.

“Hmm?” The other Levi cooed, starting to slowly pull down his boxers and pants to expose his ass, “Would you like it if I stuck my cock up your ass? I bet you would. Have you ever fucked him before, Levi?”

His Levi shook his head, lifting it a little from Erwin’s skin to respond, “No, he won’t let me. But I want to.”

“Well you might get your chance today,” the Paradisian teased, using both hands to spread Erwin’s cheeks, the cold air hitting his entrance and causing him to gasp, “He’s already hard just from this. I haven’t even done anything yet.”

Erwin wriggled his ass a little, biting his lip and muttering, “You can try, but I seriously doubt you’ll make me cum.”

There was a soft chuckle shared between the two Levi’s before a wet finger ran up and down the parting of his cheeks, ghosting his entrance before circling the rim. Erwin tried to move his hands, but his Levi had quite the grip on his wrists, and he was surprised as a whine escaped him when the digit pressed into him.

“Oh?” He could practically hear the smirk on the Paradisian’s face, “Did you hear that? I think he likes it.”

Erwin huffed with some annoyance as the two laughed a little at his expense, feeling incredibly embarrassed. His face was certainly red as he realized just how much he liked the finger groping around at his insides.

“Mmm,” he moaned, unable to help himself as Levi added a second finger, his nimble digits working at scissoring and stretching his hole, “Oh shit.”

His Levi slowly removed himself from the man’s back, moving to sit in front of his lover as he still held tightly to Erwin’s wrists so he couldn’t move. He adjusted his glasses slightly, eyes focused in on Erwin’s pleasured look.

“Oh, he looks so beautiful like this,” Levi sighed contently, “You should see his face right now. I can’t wait to see it when there’s a cock inside him.”

Erwin groaned at the thought, starting to warm up to the idea of the Levi’s fucking him. Maybe he would cum from it, but he still doubted it. Just because he was enjoying himself didn’t mean he was going to cum simply from being fucked, right? It was a rare occurrence for his Levi to cum untouched, and it would be wildly embarrassing for him if he came untouched on his first fucking.

“He’s being too loud,” Levi murmured from behind him as he added a third finger and Erwin cried out from it, “You want to shut him up?”

“Gladly,” his Levi said with a slight grin, shuffling his position so that his cock was now in front of Erwin’s mouth, “Open up, love. You need something in that pretty mouth to keep you quiet.”

Erwin wasn’t new to sucking Levi’s dick, but it was a little different in this position. Usually, he would suck Levi’s dick while fucking his fingers into him to prep him for a good fuck, but now, this was a position of submission, and he was certainly new to that.

But he opened up his mouth reluctantly, letting Levi tap it on his lower lip before pushing it inside. He could already feel his eyes half-lidded in lust, three fingers fucking his ass while a cock thrusted slowly in and out of his mouth.

“That’s it,” his Levi cooed, “You’re doing so well, Ervy. I’m proud of you.”

Erwin moaned loudly around the cock as the other Levi curled his fingers and started fucking against his prostate. It felt so good; he’d never had his prostate played with, and he was shocked by how amazing it felt. Was this why it was so easy to make his Levi unravel?

His Levi let go of his wrists in favor of gripping his hair, fucking into his mouth at a more brutal pace now, the sound of Erwin almost choking on his dick echoing throughout the room. The fingers inside him were still fucking against his prostate harshly, and his pre-cum was staining the sheets as his cock twitched from all the pleasure.

The Marleyan Levi removed his penis from Erwin’s mouth after a little while, doing something that he’d done to Levi many a time: he slapped it hard across his cheek, causing his head to go to the side.

“You want another?” His Levi asked, and the Paradisian was chuckling at what his clone had done.

Erwin stared up at him with a pleasured look before nodding eagerly, soon receiving another blow from the cock hitting him across the cheek. He groaned from the feeling, pre-cum painting his cheek now.

“Shh,” his Levi teased, “Levi’s going to start fucking you soon, and I wanna hear your little noises, okay? But I want you to beg him for his cock. Come on, let’s hear it.”

Erwin opened his mouth and closed it again, unsure of how to really beg for it. He tried to think back to what his Levi would say, and the words were suddenly spilling out of him as he wanted the pleasure to continue, “P-Please… I need it- fuck. Please, Levi.”

“You want this cock?” The other Levi murmured, removing his fingers slowly before sliding his cock in between his cheeks and rubbing it against his needy hole.

“Ohh,” he moaned, lulling his head up and down in a nod, “Oh yes. Yes, I want- ah!”

Levi started pushing in, the tip being sucked in with a flop before the wet noise of his pre-cum-covered cock entering the lubed-up entrance filled the room. Erwin’s fingers dug into the sheets, his Levi tilting his chin up so he could see Erwin’s face as the cock entered him.

“Please,” he begged, only wanting more the more he received, “Oh please oh please- oh god.”

“He sounds so desperate,” the Paradisian noted as he bottomed out.

“You should see his face,” Marley Levi smiled smugly, “Looks so fucked out- like he needs your cock to live.”

“I need it,” Erwin nodded quickly, fully into it now and only craving more, “I do, I need it so bad.”

“Hmph,” the other Levi chuckled, “So desperate for cock. Are you even this desperate for it, Levi? I know I’ve never been as eager as this one is. Gets one cock up his ass and he’s turned into a cock-hungry whore.”

Erwin moaned at his words, squirming a little as he waited for Levi to move, but the man teasingly stayed still inside him. His Levi giggled softly and shook his head, “I’ve never been this desperate this quickly- he’s certainly hungry for it. You gonna give him a rough fucking?”

“Maybe,” Levi muttered from behind him, staying in place, “I just like the thought of him being my little cock warmer right now. But maybe he can change my mind. You think you can do that, my slutty boy?”

Erwin groaned and nodded again, “P-Please, Levi. Please. M-Move- I need it. I’m such a slut for it.”

“Aww, so cute,” the Paradisian cooed, rocking his erection in and out slowly at first before pulling out all the way and fucking back in with a powerful thrust that caused Erwin to squeal loudly, “He really likes it, don’t you, baby?”

Erwin whined, grasping at the sheets as Levi began pumping in and out of him at a steady pace, “Oh yes oh yes oh yes! Oh god, give it to me!”

“Hush, my love,” his Levi murmured, stroking his hair soothingly, “The whole building’s gonna hear you.”

“Let them,” Paradis Levi snarled, delivering a harsh smack to Erwin’s behind before gripping his hips and giving his cock to the man a little rougher than before, “I think everyone needs to hear what a desperate little whore Warrior Smith is in bed. Begging and moaning for a Paradisian’s cock like he was made to take it.”

“Can… Can I have a turn?” The Marleyan Levi asked timidly, his cheeks dusted red and his eyes blown out with lust from watching his lover getting fucked and enjoying it so damn much, “I want to put it in him.”

“I think his hole can take two,” Paradis Levi replied as he continued to fuck away unrelentingly at the hole below him, Erwin squealing and mewling at every thrust as he clung to the bed sheets.

“Would you like that, Ervy?” His Levi asked, “You want two cocks inside you?”

“Oh god yes,” Erwin nodded, “Yeah, put it in. Put it in me, please.”

The Marleyan Levi leaned down to press a quick kiss to his lips before he settled his legs on either side of Erwin’s lower back, positioning his cock alongside Levi’s. The second dick was slowly pushed inside with the first, the burn of the stretch causing Erwin to gasp. It was a little painful and uncomfortable for a moment, but one of the Levi’s (he couldn’t tell which) grabbed his erection and tugged it a couple times to soothe the pain with a mix of pleasure.

“Oh fuck!” Erwin cried out as they started pounding away inside him, “Oh god! Oh god- I… I can’t- I’m so close!”

“You can,” the Paradisian growled, “And you’re going to. You’re gonna take every inch of it.”

“Ohh!” Erwin moaned, “Oh god oh fuck- please, please!”

The two were tearing at his insides, fucking into his prostate ruthlessly. He let out a choked sob, scraping desperately at the sheets below him as tears flowed down his face from the overwhelming sensation of it all.

“Please what, baby?” Paradis Levi asked, the two pounding into him one thrust after another, “Are you cumming?”

Erwin nodded, unable to form words anymore. He was practically drooling now, eyes barely open as he just took whatever they gave him. He was so close; his cock rubbing against the sheets with every thrust. Finally, his orgasm tore through him; a full-body thing that had his legs shaking and his arms twitching, a shriek escaping his mouth. He rested his head on the sheets, feeling spent as the two continued to fuck into his sensitive hole. Erwin could hear the sounds of the two making out behind him, and soon felt his hole being filled with cum, the two pulling out slowly.

“How was that, lovely?” Marley Levi asked, getting off him and kissing the top of his head.

“So good,” he muttered sleepily, “So good.”

Paradis Levi slapped his ass for good measure, “I told you you’d like it.”

Erwin groaned at the feeling, sighing contently, “I get to take turns on you two next time.”

He could hear the two exchanging laughter before Marley Levi laid next to him and snuggled up to him, pressing kisses to his face, “Whatever you want, baby.”

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~